BioWare’s Patrick Weekes has agreed with elements of the excel expose, but defends why they take that approach. Gamers ”can understand it.”
”Though their games are original, well-written and fun, I’ve always found similarities in BioWare RPGs – particular clichés unique to their games and even a few of Obsidian’s,” posted Hellforge in their article piece, reports Eurogamer.
”…I decided to make my own chart based on my experience with their games over the years.” The chart is over on the Hellforge website, and it has attracted BioWare.
”So I’m supposed to believe someone is smart enough to do a big Excel spreadsheet with color coding and stuff but not smart enough to know about Campbellian archetypes?” posted BioWare’s Weekes on the Mass Effect forums. Here’s the rest of it:
”Yeah, guys, every BioWare game has the same plot! See, things are kind of normal, and then things change and you have to go out and do stuff, and you go to crazy weird places! Aaaaaand so yeah, totally the same story.”
“That’s asinine.”
“The core idea isn’t that bad – I sense that someone started out with a good concept, like “Hey, you go to four places a lot,” and then they just decided to add some more filler rows to try to make a real zinger, except that when you actually read the cells, a lot of them are stretches.”
“In any event, the “intro, four planets, finale” structure is something we have used often for a few simple reasons:”
“1) It’s easy. It’s not as easy as making the player do everything in order, but you can generally just treat each area separately except for a few variables, which makes logic-testing and QA work a ton easier. What happens on Feros stays on Feros. BioWare knows how to make these games, make them solid and workable, and ship them – and if need be, we can always cut areas, which sucks, but we can do it if need be. Some structures don’t allow for that, which is why you end up with games where it’s clear that the devs ran out of time or money at some point.”
“2) Players can understand it. In usability tests on one project, we learned that players with more than four things to do at a time in any given area will feel frustrated – they get overwhelmed and have no idea what to do first and get the names mixed up. So you don’t dump twenty small planets on the player all at once. You hit them with a few big things that they can understand: “Go to Feros.” And then once they’re there, they unlock several different things to do that don’t compete with the rest of the universe, because right now you’re on Feros. “Kill Varren.” “Get Power Cells.” “Turn on Water Valves.” “Go to ExoGeni.” (And we even cheat a bit by giving you missions, which are big and obvious, and assignments, which we tell you are less important.)”
“In testing out our missions for ME2, the single biggest lump of story feedback we’ve gotten has boiled down to Information Flow. When a mission feels clunky, nine times out of ten it’s because we either told the player way too much all at once and expected the player to keep it all straight, or we didn’t actually tell the player enough and so the player is kind of lost. Dividing up our game into four or five large worlds allows us to control information a bit better.”
“(And to be clear, that four-worlds-and-out thing is a simplification that ignores major critpath events and makes it sound like you only visit four big areas in KotOR, which flat-out isn’t true.)”
“3) There’s nothing wrong with it. It’s a structure, like any other. Humorously snarking that our games have a beginning part that is streamlined and introduces you to the game, a middle that allows you the freedom to go to several places and have adventures, and then a tightly focused ending is like riffing on how romance novels generally start out with two people being attracted to each other but having emotional issues, then gradually building trust, then having a complication that splits them up, and then in the end they get together and are happy. People who create fiction in any form use a structure appropriate to that form. They do it because their audience understands and responds on an emotional level to that structure.”
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic and Mass Effect do share the same narrative formula, but has that made them any less an experience for you, videogamer?
